Do Star Performers Make Good Leaders?
Friday, October 23rd, 2009
Hope and faith are important things. I don’t think that humans could survive with out hope and faith. Unfortuately, too often hope and faith are used to make promotional decisions.
Case on point: hoping that the Star Performer will become a Star Leader.
By placing faith in a Star Performer to transform into a Star Leader is foolish. A well-intentioned, but foolish, choice that places the organizatioh at risk and can negatively impact peoples lives.
It is often said that “people don’t leave companies; they leave bosses.” The traits that make some one look like great pomotion potential from above: task focused, high achiever, go-getter, works well with out direction, innovator, driven are THE SAME traits that can make poor leaders.
Why?
Because the go-getter attitude may sideline important LEADERSHIP TRAITS such as empathy, time to listen, relationship building, willingness to listen to contrary opinions, in short…all those elements that insprie TRUST in others.
Without TRUST from those who CHOOSE to follow-there is NO LEADER . Therefore, NO LEADERSHIP.
So look beyond, the Star Performance. Look to the ACTUAL STAR LEADERSHIP that currently exists.
Who do people TRUST in the organization?
Who looks out for their TEAM as much as themselves?
Who continually holds themselves ACCOUNTABLE?
Who is ADMIRED by thier peers, not just liked by those up the food chain?
Who has a THIRST for learning?
Who has the HUMILITY to know that there is alot to learn-no matter how long they have been around the block?
Who WOULD YOU CHOOSE TO FOLLOW COME HELL OR HIGH WATER OR BOTH?








their leaders to control, moderate, address bad stuff at work. So when I found this article from HR Executive online I stood up and cheered.
Conflict, conflict, conflict. I love conflict. It is amazing what lengths managers and companies go to to avoid addressing conflict. I regularly attend a local Recognition Roundtable sponsored by Recognition Works. Simply, it is an informal gathering of employees who are trying to create or sustain recognition programs. Why do I go? Because sometimes -well … often – employees and managers mistakenly try to use a recognition program to address a workplace conflict issue.